• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Minafi

Financial Independence Through Investing, Minimalism & Mindfulness

  • Minafi
  • Start Investing
    • Article Series
  • Learn
    • Start Here
  • Calculators
    • ESPP Calculator
    • Bonus Tax Calculator
    • Rule of 72 Calculator
    • FI with Options Calculator
  • FIRE Guide
    • FIRE Guide
    • FIRE in the News
  • About
    • About Adam & Minafi
    • Vision & Mission
    • Income & Expenses
    • Recommendations: Tools I Use
    • My Net Worth Reports
    • Contact Me
  • Blog
    • Investing
    • Financial Independence
    • Mindfulness
    • Minimalism
    • Personal
    • Goals
  • Search

Blog

August 2020 Theme: Empty

Written by Adam on August 9, 2020. Updated January 7, 2023.
6 min read. Personal, Goals, Blog. 2 Comments

For all of 2020, I’m trying something different. Every month I’m setting a theme. As part of that theme, I’m also setting goals and habits to help it along the way. These themes aren’t limited to the month. Each is for the entire year and in addition to everything else added before it.

It’s August now, which means this is the 8th month with a theme. So

  • January:  Focus
  • February: Finish
  • March: Routine
  • April: Create
  • May: Work
  • June: Explore
  • July: Vision
  • August: Empty

I picked these themes based on what I felt was the most important at the time to help stay emotionally grounded, productive, and happy.

Push to reset the world

Last Months Theme: Vision

For July, my theme was vision. A vision for the future seemed to be something I was missing this year. Like a lot of people, our lives are very much in a holding position – waiting for this pandemic to end.

My hope was that by spending a month with “vision” in the forefront of my mind I would magically come up with a more clear reason for why I was working on the things I’m currently working on. That’s obviously not the way motivation works. If you’re struggling to do something difficult, even if it’s to accomplish a goal you believe you, what you’re most lacking isn’t vision – it’s grit.

For last month’s theme I tried to do a few things:

I revised my 101 Things I Want to Know, Have, Do or Be list. Just creating this list was inspiring. It made me feel more excited about the future – even if it’ll be years before I hit up Oktoberfest, see the northern lights or visit every National Park.

Created a local bucket list of activities that I can only do within a day of home. This involved researching local spots, talking with friends for recommendations, and filtering it down to what was most exciting. Many of these activities are COVID-19 friendly too.

There was one unexpected result of this month’s theme: a better understanding of what role I want Minafi to play in my life. When I stopped working about a year and a half ago, I jumped fully into working on Minafi. I’m not working full-time on it like a job, but I’ve definitely been putting in the hours to turn the many ideas in my head into interactive posts, courses, a fund directory, and so much more.

Thinking more about what role I want Minafi to play in my life caused me to realize what I want and don’t want out of it:

I don’t want Minafi to be (or feel like) a job. I don’t want to have to release content on a specific cadence. I don’t want to be an “influencer” or be constantly Tweeting about new takes. I don’t want to spend time organizing large groups of people. I don’t want to constantly be writing SEO articles.

Pie and beer day
“Pioneer Day” is a Mormon holiday. “Pie and Beer Day” is a non-mormon holiday we celebrate!

Instead, I want Minafi to be a playground. It’s a place to create whatever strikes me as fun and useful. I don’t mind organizing or being a part of smaller groups. I’m more interested in going The Mad Fientest route where I spend my time on what I’m most enthusiastic to work on.

So what does that mean for Minafi going forward? Not too much will change actually. For the last few months, I’ve spent a lot of time working on The Minafi Investor Bootcamp and the Fund Directory. Now I plan to take a little break and spend time working on some non-Minafi projects.

In June (Explore) I started learning iOS development (which I’ve tried to learn a few times). It’s been a lot of fun so far. I have an app in mind I want to build that’ll be primarily just for me to use.

Weller Lake Trail Bridge in Aspen
Weller Lake Trail Bridge in Aspen

Jumping straight into a project after leaving a job is a great identity bridge – a way to maintain a similar sense of self during a major life change. For me, Minafi has been that bridge. 18 months later it feels like that bridge has done its job, but I’m ready to do something else. What that something else is? I have no clue.

There is something I do know though: I truly enjoy working on long-term projects that can grow over time. Even if those projects change, I love having things that I’m passionate about and care about to work on.

It’s only by taking a break from the current projects that we can open doors to new projects. Not having anything to work on can feel completely aimless, or it can be empowering! In June (Explore) I tried opening myself up to try new things. The result? I learned some new programming skills (GraphQL for one), started learning iOS development, learning some DevOps skills to setup a site on Digital Ocean, and ended up creating a whole new website for fun (just for personal use – we’ll see if I ever share it out).

August Theme: Empty

The takeaway from this experience hasn’t made sense all at once, but after some reflection, it’s come into focus:

The best to open yourself up to new opportunities is to stop what you’re currently doing and be open to them.

Why Empty?

As for why “empty”? It comes from the very old phrase: “Empty Your Cup”. It’s often associated with martial arts teaching. It’s a story I’ve always loved, but haven’t always embraced:

A master was attempting to teach a student a new move. The student was struggling and would fail over and over. The problem wasn’t that the student was unskilled, but they were attempting to hold on to their current mental models.

The master sat down to pour them both some tea. After pouring both cups, the master told the student he wanted to give him some more tea from his cup.

The student panicked, “my cup is full! I can’t accept any more tea until empty my cup”. The master replied, “yes I know. And I can’t give you any more ideas or life lessons until you clear your mind and make room for them.”

The student pondered for a moment with a look of absolute bewilderment. Then a look of enlightenment came over him, followed by a smile, and a look of receptiveness. The master started to explain again, and this time the student saw what the master was trying to say.

If that sounds scary, it’s because it is! In the case of interests, hobbies, and personal projects it’s obviously much easier to pause and reflect than in a career, but the idea is the same.

Have you ever taken a vacation then returned back to your job with a new and fresh set of eyes? Maybe you were able to see past problems in a new light or come up with unseen solutions. Or maybe by coming back you realized this wasn’t the job for you after all.

Getting to that feeling with my own personal projects is my theme for August. Spending some time with my mind away from what I usually spend time on.

Maybe during that time away, I’ll find something new to spend time on. Maybe I’ll return to what I’m working on reinvigorated and ready to tackle projects I’ve already thought about. Maybe I’ll wipe the slate clean and work on something else, or with something else?

At this point I’m not sure. Only some time away will tell!

And don’t worry, there’s no way I intend to completely stop working on things here on Minafi. If anything I hope to be more strategic with my time – focusing on the parts that make me the happiest: writing new articles and creating more interactive articles!

Have you ever tried “emptying your cup”? How did it go?

Why You Should Create a Local Bucket List

Written by Adam on July 27, 2020. Updated January 7, 2023.
6 min read. Personal, Mindfulness, Financial Independence, Travel, Blog. 9 Comments

Earlier this month I realized one missing piece in our life lately: a vision of the future. Planning for the future seems impossible when everything is still in flux.

Or at least, it can seem that way. For July, I’m trying to break out of that mindset and embrace a vision of the future – even if it may change.

The view from Ensign Peak in SLC.
[Read more…] about Why You Should Create a Local Bucket List

7 Mindsets to Thrive in Financial Independence

Written by Adam on July 20, 2020. Updated January 8, 2023.
12 min read. Canonical, Minafi, Personal, Mindfulness, Blog. 3 Comments

The path to financial independence has two main components: money and mindset. The money side is appealing to focus on. You can optimize it, schedule it, plan it, and even complete it! Once you have the money side on autopilot, there’s very little to do.

That’s where having the right mindset matters. There’s not just one mindset that determines happiness; you need many! Some mindsets improve your relationships, others your productivity. Some increase appreciation of life, and others let you make more of it.

Adam at Mill B North Trail in SLC
Adam at Mill B North Trail in SLC

Just knowing that a mindset exists can be a step towards changing your behavior! These 7 mindsets are ones I attempt to foster (sometimes successfully).

1. Compound Interest Mindset

In the money world, we talk a lot about compound interest. It’s what allows people to retire early using index funds, students to become masters, and viruses to spread to entire populations in record speed.

It’s also what allows you to grow your wealth using the blue line on the graph below.

A compound interest mindset isn’t limited to money. Continuous investment pays off in every aspect of life that you want to cultivate.

Continuous learning allows you to become an expert. You don’t need to become an expert in your 20s! You can begin playing violin in your 70s, or switch to a coding career after college. What matters is putting in the work to learn and slowly get better. Just putting in 1 hour a week to get better at your job will cause you to outshine your coworkers who stand still over time.

Continuous investments in relationships allow them to reach new levels. One of the reasons why so many life-long friendships are started in college is because we put in the time. It’s more difficult to do that later when life gets in the way.

Continuous giving allows your efforts to grow. You may start volunteering somewhere and realize everyone is helping you. After a few times, you may be training others and begin to see your efforts to help multiply.

James Clear calls this “The Power of Tiny Gains”. The difference between getting 1% and 1% worse daily for a year is 1259 times! Getting 1% better every day may be unrealistic after a point. Nothing says you can’t strive to get 1% better every week, or every month.

ChooseFI calls this same approach The Aggregation of Marginal Gains. The difference between doing the tiniest bit of effort and nothing at all doesn’t show in short term. It’s only when kept up long-term that it pays off.

One thing I’m currently attempting to get 1% better at is Japanese. I’ve been an anime fan since high school, took a class in college, and visited twice (including for our honeymoon). I’ve attempted to learn a few times, but never stayed with it.

What I realized was that I was trying too hard. What was important wasn’t making the most progress in the shortest time. It was making sustained progress. That’s the key to compound interest. You find a way to keep going. You do by not making it suck.

Since I discovered that, I’ve scaled back how much time I spend trying to learn Japanese. I’ll do some spaced repetition using WaniKani, do a Kanji/Hiragana drill every few weeks and occasionally try to read a kids book. This is a pace I enjoy, and even look forward to!

The same trap happens with money. So many people (myself included) learn about financial independence and cut their spending to a level so low they no longer have anything to look forward to. Time after time I read about people reaching this point then splurging on large expenses – a new house, a luxurious trip.

I prefer this approach – finding my limit. It allows me to understand how far is too far. The next step is the important one: figure out how to make sustained progress. That, more than anything, is how to develop a compound interest mindset.

2. Growth Mindset

Growth mindset and fixed mindset have gotten a lot of attention lately. The quick explanation of the difference between these two comes down to this question:

Do you believe your personality, personal limits and boundaries are set in stone? Or do you believe they’re whatever you make of them?

Those that believe that you can break through these limits in anything in your life follow a growth mindset. Those that believe they can’t follow a fixed mindset. (note: this is a within the boundaries of what you’re physically capable of).

Growth mindset and fixed mindset aren’t all-encompassing. You may believe in a growth mindset for almost everything in life, and still have a few “fixed mindset” areas.

For me, I’ve struggled with a fixed mindset in a few areas in particular:

I’m not an athlete. I grew up with rather severe asthma. I couldn’t run a mile without an inhaler and a gasping break. It wasn’t until I joined CrossFit and slowly saw my strength increase over years of action (compound interest) that I began to realize this was a fixed mindset. I could still be an athlete with asthma.

I’m not that smart. I finished 104th out of 106 in my high school class. That wasn’t because I was dumb. It was because I was lazy and never learned how to study. Many people (especially millennials) make it through high school and college without much work. When they get into the real world they realize that it’s not about being “smart” – it’s about “doing the work”. I came to this realization when I created my first successful website in college (if you’re curious it was about the game Dance Dance Revolution). It was only then I began to realize the difference between book-smart and real-world knowledge.

I’m an introvert. This is the one I hear the most. Thinking of yourself as an introvert can be a fixed mindset! You may still draw energy more from being alone than being around people (as I do), but that doesn’t mean you can’t also be outgoing! I was extremely shy in high school outside of my close friends’ group.

It wasn’t until much later that I realized how much I enjoy many “extrovert” activities in the right situations. As a product manager, I interviewed hundreds of people to learn more about how to improve products I worked on even though I sometimes have struggled to hold a conversation. I’ve given hundreds of presentations about topics I’m passionate about; even though I hated giving presentations in school. At FinCon I talked to so many people I realized I’d chatted with 1% of all conference-goers.

For me, I found that one of the reasons I considered myself an introvert was because the conversation wasn’t about things I cared about. As soon as it was, I could chat all day with other passionate people.

Me giving a talk at FinCon ’19

Paula Pant did an episode recently about how Personality Isn’t Permanent which is a great introduction to growth mindset if you’re curious to learn more.

3. Abundance Mindset

How do you react to limitations and obstacles? Those with an abundance mindset turn road-blocks into fuel, propelling them to find an even better route than they could otherwise. This leaves them excited and motivated to solve the problem in front of them. They believe there are other solutions out there.

Those with a scarcity mindset do the opposite. They throw their hands up, and think “what now?” or “why me?” (which is more of a victim mindset – but that’s another story). Rather than trying to find a way around the problem, they wallow. They hold onto what they have because they worry there’ll never get anything as good ever again.

In the simplest terms, the scarcity mindset is the belief that there will never be enough — whether it’s money, food, emotions or something else entirely — and as a result, your actions and thought stem from a place of lack. Instead of believing that you have enough, and there is plenty to go around, you cling to everything you have out of fear of coming up short.

Scarcity mindset

Scarcity mindset and abundance mindset are often trained from an early age. If you grew up in a house where you heard “no” over and over, it’s possible to begin your life like this. You hold on to everything you have because you don’t know when you’ll ever be able to get it again.

It’s why hoarders pack their houses with stuff, why many millionaires and billionaires don’t give much to charity, why people stay in bad relationships, and why some people withdraw from striving for a better future.

One of my favorite words in a non-English language is lagom. It loosely translates to “the understanding that I have enough”. It’s not about abundance, or just getting by. It’s the exact amount you need.

There’s no English equivalent to this. That alone shows how much we struggle to find “enough” in the US.

There’s buying enough space in your house, saving enough money, investing money, and taking enough risk. How much money is “enough”?

The top 1% of wealthiest people in the world

Account for over 50% of the worlds wealth

What are you doing to join that 1%? ?

— RJ | Hustle & Invest ? (@RJTheHustler) July 16, 2020

My guess is that you don’t need to be in the top 1% to be happy. If you need a private jet to take you to a private island to be happy I suspect there are other issues. How much is enough?

There’s having enough relationships, buying enough things – even optimizing enough (I can go overboard optimizing).

In my career, I worked to optimize profit. That involved releasing programming courses and content that were at the intersection of fast, good, and on a subject that people were interested in.

Now though, what I’m optimizing for isn’t money – and it’s been weird. I’m 18 months into retraining my brain to optimize for happiness. It’s part of the reason why I initially priced The Minafi Investor Bootcamp at $229 before lowering the price to “pay-whatever-you-want”. It took a while for me to realize I had enough and I didn’t need to claw back every dollar by maximizing the cost.

Why Pay-Whatever?

The former startup employee in me defaulted to maximizing for money. After completing the content, I just wanted more people to have access to it!

I'm fortunate to be in a financial position where I don't _need_ to maximize for money – so I'm not. 3/9

— Adam @ Minafi (@minafiblog) July 16, 2020

I still consider myself a minimalist. To me a minimalist someone who strives to have enough. It’s someone who’s constantly questioning what they have and asking if it’s too much or not enough. It’s that constant improvement towards lagom that’s the journey.

Developing an abundance mindset takes time. I still have a ways to go.

4. Ranged Mindset

The ability to think in ranges is a professional superpower.

When someone asks you how long you think it’ll take to accomplish a task laid out in front of you, how do you answer?

Do you say 4 hours, about 4 hours or “between 2 and 8 hours“.

I’ll be honest: giving your manager ranges for time estimates rather than exact guesses may annoy them. Another option is to say “between 2 and 8 hours. After 2 hours I can let you know a better estimate.”

One of my favorite books on the topic is Software Estimation: Demystifying the Black Art. It’s seriously worth a read if you’re a software developer. It focuses on shifting your mindset to think in ranges defined by the unknowns.

The greater the unknowns, the larger the range. As you learn more about a problem and how to solve it, there are fewer unknowns and the range decreases. Eventually, the high and low estimates intersect. That’s the actual time.

We’re taught in school to give precise answers to questions. Later in life, many answers aren’t quite so black in white.

The same is true for your money.

Rather than thinking of your Financial Independence Number as a single number, try thinking of it as a range. The low end is lean FI and the high end is Fat FI.

As you learn more about what you want out of life, you may realize you need more money than your lean FI number to be happy. Or you may realize that the high-end of Fat FI is overly luxurious and not worth it. That helps to focus in on your real number – or your FIO number.

5. Slow and Steady Mindset

You could call this another part of the compound interest mindset. I have an approach I use whenever I work on anything. It looks like this:

Maximize effort early, sustain effort later

I start off by getting extremely invested in a subject (obsessed would be a better description). I put in a ton of work in up front and try to make it over The Dip (as Seth Godin calls it). If I do, I keep going, but at a balanced pace.

Once you know how to make progress, the next question is how can you continue making progress with less work? This is the programmer in me trying to optimize for time – something you can never earn back.

This coast mentality is the same approach countless others advise to grow wealth. Rather than trying to figure out how much you can do, try to think about how little you can do.

The amount of progress you make may be different. If you practice learning an instrument 1 hour a day, you’ll progress a lot faster than if you only practice for 30 minutes. The difference is how many years you practice for. A fast pace doesn’t matter if you don’t keep going.

A few years ago I tried to learn how to play the piano. I went to weekly lessons for months and practiced at home at night. It wasn’t my intent to become a master, but I did want to be able to play some Beatles covers and music from Final Fantasy.

Eventually, I gave it up. It wasn’t because I stopped wanting those things, but it was because I hadn’t found a way to enjoy practicing. I had spread myself too thin between various projects and I hadn’t taken the time to get past that initial bump.

When trying to grow a skill or anything else that takes time, find a way to enjoy the journey.

6. It’s Not About You Mindset

Back when I worked at Code School we did a week-long leadership training course. There were long days, sharing of feelings, and a lot of crying (sooo much crying). There’s one phrase that stuck with me even after the week ended:

It’s not about you, it’s about them.

When someone says, posts or tweets something that rubs you the wrong way, remember: this isn’t about you, it’s about them.

When someone tweets about “how <insert life> isn’t retirement”, or “everyone should invest in Tesla”, or “only lucky people can retire”, it’s their point of view based on all of their life decisions up until this point. It’s not an argument, it’s just their point of view – and you don’t need to try to change them.

Not getting defensive when you’re provoked is a skill and one I’m very far from myself. By approaching provocation from a position of “why” rather than “you’re wrong”, it helps get to the heart of their issue. It starts the conversation from attempting to understand their point of view.

Is this a personal relationship with someone that’s in jeopardy, or just an internet argument? If it’s a personal relationship you can jump on a call, ask them how they’re feeling, why they’re feeling that way and try to learn more.

If it’s an internet argument…. do you really need to respond? If it’s a subject you’re passionate about I’d encourage it. Some people are MUCH better at this than I am.

The approach when facing someone with a differing opinion isn’t the same as someone with a racist or bigoted mindset. Differing opinions can be ignored, but racism must be confronted.

In a professional environment, or in your personal relationships, when someone does something that rubs you the wrong way – seek more context! Ask them about why they feel that way. Empathize and understand how they came to that conclusion.

Try to understand your own defense mechanisms. When confronted do you act defensively? Do you try to rationalize your decision? Do you avoid the confrontation altogether? Do you passive-aggressively shut down the talk? None of these help, and now you have two problems.

Trying to get to the root of disagreements comes from understanding why, not by proving your innocence.

7. Now Mindset

Have you ever said the following phrase, either out loud or in your mind:

I’ll do it when I leave my job and have more time.

It’s an alluring trap to fall into. You dream of a future when you have enough time to learn new things, explore new places, and take on those some day projects that just thinking about give you butterflies in your stomach.

A now mindset looks at these dreams and asks “what can I do right now?”. You break down a large project into steps and find out how to make progress on it now.

One example I love is hiking the Appalachian Trail. It takes roughly 6 months to do and would not be possible for most people working a full-time job.

Overnight backpacking trip to Amethyst Lake outside of Salt Lake

Those with a later mindset would put off the hike until they leave their job. At that point, they buy all their gear, tear off all the tags, head to Springer Mountain in Georgia where the trail starts, and begin their hike. They’re also more likely to give up.

The reason they give up is that they’re starting at the end. You wouldn’t run a marathon without training for it, so why expect yourself to survive a 6-month hike?

Someone with a Now Mindset will find ways to make progress while they’re working. They go on weekend hikes and backpacking trips. They test their gear today and iterate based on what works. They may even realize they’d rather go on a week-long trip than a multi-month odyssey.

I romanticized the idea of a long hike, but quickly found I’d be much happier with a weekend trip with friends. I’m happy I realized this now rather than while on the trail. It’s one reason why my July theme is Vision.

The same can be done with your “when I retire” projects. Why can’t you learn that skill/language/instrument now? What’s stopping you from achieving those fitness goals today? Why can’t you make that change in your spending now?

It’s a running joke that with everything happening in 2020, it isn’t the year to make progress on anything.

I’d challenge you to think about it another way: when you need a break from the endless news cycle, what do you do? Is there something you could work on now?

The answer might be no. Some people are navigating unemployment while teaching kids at home and trying to make ends meet. It’s only after you’ve taken care of your mental health that you can begin to consider personal growth (and improving mental health is personal growth!)

If you find yourself in a downward spiral of checking news and twitter on repeat, then you have room to tackle a long-term project now. Try pausing news to take time to figure out what project you want to work on. Research it, get inspired about it – and then do it.

July 2020 Theme: Vision

Written by Adam on July 5, 2020. Updated January 7, 2023.
8 min read. Personal, Goals, Blog. 2 Comments

For all of 2020, I’m trying something different. Every month I’m setting a theme. As part of that theme, I’m also setting goals and habits to help it along the way. These themes aren’t limited to the month. Each is for the entire year and in addition to everything else added before it.

For January my theme was Focus, for February it was Finish, for March, Routine, for April Create, for May Work and for June Explore. I picked these themes based on what I felt was the most important at the time to help stay emotionally grounded, productive, and happy. 

Side note: Check out the bottom of any of these “theme posts” to hear about how it went.

Pages: Page 1 Page 2

The Complete Guide to Withdrawing Funds Early From Your 401(k), IRA and Roth IRA

Written by Adam on June 29, 2020. Updated January 8, 2023.
10 min read. Investing, Taxes, Blog, Minafi, Canonical. 9 Comments

Retirement accounts are some of the best possible ways to save money during your working years. They allow you to defer taxes – either now or later – and reap the rewards of compound growth without compound taxes.

But there’s a catch.

You can’t withdraw money from your 401(k), IRA, or Roth IRA at any time. If you take out money from these accounts before you’re 59 ½, you may be hit by a 10% early withdrawal penalty. It’s like your money is in a safe, and you can’t get the combination until you reach that age.

There is some good news though! For each of these account types, there are ways to access your money early without paying this penalty. In this article, we’ll look at a few tax efficient retirement withdrawal strategies YOU can use to withdraw money from these accounts before you meet the age requirement.

The Problem

The three most popular retirement accounts used in the United States are the 401(k), the Traditional Individual Retirement Account (also just called an IRA), and the Roth IRA. Each has slightly different rules for accessing them.

This article focuses on the “how” but doesn’t answer the question of “should you?”. My personal opinion is that you shouldn’t access these accounts unless you’re experiencing a tremendous hardship, or you’ve retired and have worked out how to live off of them going forward.

These “early access” and “withdraw penalty” are assuming you use none of the techniques discussed in this article to access these funds early.

 401(k)Traditional IRARoth IRA
Earliest Full Access59½59½59½
Earliest Possible Access55
You can access the account only of a job you leave.
59½59½
Early Withdrawal Penalty10% penalty10% penalty

0% penalty
For withdrawing contributions.


10% penalty
for additional withdrawals

Required Minimum Distribution72 years old
(age 70½ if born before July 1, 1949)
70½ ~ 72 years old
Read more on the IRS Website
None!
Yearly Contribution Limit$19,500

$26,000 when 50+
$6,000
for IRA + Roth IRA

$7,000
when 50+
$6,000
for IRA + Roth IRA

$7,000
when 50+
Early Withdrawal Options• Rule of 55
• Cares Act
• Roth IRA Ladder
• 72t Distribution
• Hardship Distribution
• First Home Purchase
• Cares Act
• First Home Purchase
• Roth IRA Conversion Ladder
• 72t Distribution
• First Home Purchase
• Contribution Withdraw

The 401k early withdrawal penalty is the most severe one that most people will face. Fortunately there are many strategies you can use to access the account sooner! Let’s look at them one by one.

Adam says: This post is a little long. You can skip to any strategy by clicking on the link in the table above.

Early Withdrawal Strategies

There are multiple strategies for each type of account. I’ve ordered them by easiest to implement to the most difficult.

Rule of 55 Works for: 401(k)

The Rule of 55 is an IRS provision that allows you to access the 401(k) account of your job without paying the early withdrawal penalty on two conditions:

  1. You’re at least 55 years old.
  2. You leave your job.

In practice it works like this: You have a 401(k) at job that you’ve been contributing to for years.

Keep in mind that you’ll only be able to withdraw funds from the 401(k) account from your employer. You won’t be able to access other 401(k) accounts.

There is a trick you can use though! If you know you’re going to leave your job between age 55 and 59½ you can rollover past 401(k) accounts and traditional IRA accounts you have into this one 401(k). By doing that you’re bucketing all money into your single 401(k) account you can access early – and without paying a penalty!

Contribution Withdrawal Works for: Roth IRA

There’s a reason why I recommend Roth IRA’s over IRAs whenever possible: they are the most flexible. Unlike IRA and 401(k) accounts, you can withdraw the money you deposited into a Roth IRA at any time! The only money you can’t touch without paying an early withdrawal penalty is the earnings and interest.

Let’s look at an example. Say you started maxing out your Roth IRA at age 25 – putting in $6,000 a year. You continued doing that until you’re 50 years and decided to retire early (congrats!). During that time you invested it in the stock market and it grew at 7% a year.

When you’re 50 you would have saved up $422,000. $160,000 of that was from your contributions and the rest was growth in your investments.

That means that you would be able to take out $160,000 of it at any time for any reason. You could withdraw it all at once, or $20,000 a year for 8 years.

As soon as you take out the first $1 over $160,000, you’d need to pay a 10% early withdrawal penalty on every dollar you withdraw.

As soon as you hit age 59½ that early withdrawal penalty goes away and you can take out any amount you like.

Cares Act 2020 Works for: 401(k)403(b)IRA

The Cares Act is a Coronavirus relief bill passed and enacted on March 27, 2020. Amongst other things, there’s a provision in the Cares Act that allows “qualified individuals” to withdraw up to $100,000 from their 401(k), 403(b) or IRA account within the 2020 year.

To be a “Qualified Individual”, you must meet these requirements:

  • You, your spouse or a dependent must be diagnosed with COVID-19 by a CDC approved test.
  • Experience “adverse financial consequences as a result of being quarantined, laid off, or work reduced.

The full list of requirements are listed out on the IRS page about the Cares Act in Q3.

If you meet these requirements and want to withdraw up to $100,000 you have that option in 2020!

Another nice bonus is that your taxes for this withdrawal are split over 3 years. If you withdrawal $100,000 you won’t be taxed on all of it. Instead, you’ll be taxed on $33,333.34 in 2020, $33,333.33 in 2021, and $33,333.33 in 2022. You can also choose to pay all taxes in 2020 if you want.

There’s also an option in the Cares Act that allows you to repay this withdraw within 3 years. If you are in a dire financial position now, but quickly recover, this could be a nice additional way to save more in the next few years.

First Home Purchase Works for: 401(k)403(b)IRARoth IRA

As if buying a home isn’t hard enough – there are ways to make it more confusing by tapping your retirement accounts to help with the down payment. Doing so may reduce your PMI (private mortgage insurance), which could reduce your monthly out of pocket cost.

While I’m very much pro-apartment living and repeatedly mention that your home isn’t part of the 4% rule, buying a house is a dream for most Americans.

Here’s how the home purchase would work:

  1. Be a first time home buyer (or have 2+ years pass since your last home purchase)
  2. Withdraw up to $10,000 from an IRA, up to $10,000 in earnings from your Roth IRA and/or as much as you need from a 401(k).

If you’re buying a house with your spouse, you can each withdraw $10,000 from your IRAs and $10,000 from your Roths – for a total of $40,000 towards it.

You can withdraw any amount from your 401(k) as part of a hardship distribution – which we’ll talk about next.

Related Articles:

  • Can You Use Your IRA to Buy a House?
  • Can I Use My 401(K) to Buy a House?

Hardship Distribution Works for: 401(k)403(b)

Hardship and Safe Harbor Distributions allow you to withdraw funds from your employers 401(k) or 403(b) for a “heavy financial need” without paying the early withdrawal penalty. You will still pay taxes on the withdrawal.

The tax rules on what qualifies as a “heavy financial need” are specific:

  • Medical care
  • Buying a new primary residence
  • Expenses to not be evicted from a primary residence
  • Tuition & education related expenses
  • Funeral expenses
  • Certain expenses to repair damage to a primary residence

All of these are the type of expenses are the reason why it’s ideal to have an emergency fund of at least 6-months expenses on hand.

With a hardship distribution, you can make an early withdrawal from your 401k or 403b – but only for the amount needed to cover the hardship. You can’t take out extra for a vacation or to cover food.

Roth IRA Conversion Ladder Works for: 401(k)*IRA

401(k): This approach works for a 401(k) if you convert it to an IRA first.

If you’re unable to withdraw funds from an IRA using any of the other methods, the Roth IRA Ladder strategy is your best bet.

You can use this method to withdraw ANY amount from your IRA, pay taxes on it today and spend the money in 5 years. You can use this method at any age, whether you have a job or not.

The Roth IRA Ladder works by converting money from an IRA to a Roth IRA, waiting 5 years, then withdrawing the money from your Roth IRA

The “5 years” part takes a little explanation. Let’s assume you’re 45 years old and plan to retire at age 50 and begin spending about $50,000 a year. Here’s how it works in practice:

To keep things simple, let’s assume you have $1,000,000 in your IRA and $0 in your Roth IRA. Here’s what a yearly plan might look like:

AgeIRA -> Roth ConversionYearly SpendingRoth IRA Contribution Balance
45$50,000—$50,000
46$51,000—$101,000
47$52,020—$153,020
48$53,060—$206,080
49$54,121—$260,201
50$55,203$50,000$265,404
51$56,307$51,000$270,711
52$57,433$52,020$276,124
53$58,581$53,060$281,645
54$59,753$54,121$287,277
55$0 (don’t need to!)$55,203$232,074
56$0$56,307$175,767
57$0$57,433$118,334
58$0$58,581$59,753
59$0$59,753$0
60—$60,948$0

The conversion from age 45 is spent at age 50. The conversion from age 46 is spent at age 51.

For the first 5 years of a Roth IRA Ladder, you won’t be able to access the funds from your IRA OR your Roth IRA. During that time you can use the contribution withdrawal strategy to access previously deposited funds in your Roth IRA if you have any. Otherwise, you can use the money saved up in an after-tax account or continue working.

There is a MAJOR caveat to this approach. For each year from age 45 to 54, you’ll need to pay taxes on your IRA to Roth IRA conversion. If you’re still working you may end paying a higher rate on your conversion. If you have no other way of paying these taxes, you’ll need to convert more in previous years (like 45-50) so you can use that money to pay taxes 5 years later.

The best-case solution is to have 5 years of cash in a brokerage account or use your existing IRA use the contribution withdrawal strategy. This allows you to lower your tax rate and pay fewer taxes for your IRA conversion.

Related Articles:

  • Climbing The Roth IRA Conversion Ladder To Fund Early Retirement from Root of Good
  • How to Access Retirement Funds Early from The Mad Fientist

72t Distribution Works for: 401(k)*IRA

401(k): This approach works for a 401(k) if you convert it to an IRA first.

IRS Rule 72(t) seems like a solution to all early withdrawal problems – at least at first. After reading more and trying to create a plan for it, most realize it’s actually a heavily restricting and sometimes costly mistake.

A 72t distribution allows you to withdraw money from your IRA early without paying the 10% penalty. A 72t distribution works by locking yourself into a payment plan where you withdraw a calculated, set amount each year for the rest of your life. This effectively turns your IRA into an annuity – providing income each year. The amount you can withdraw each year is based on your age (and therefore your life expectancy) and a “reasonable interest rate”.

The way it works is terribly confusing. Let’s look at an example then break it down.

First off the requirements. You must agree to take out annual withdraws for at least 5 years – or until age 59½. You can’t modify how much you withdraw each year. If you do you’ll pay a 10% early distribution penalty retroactively since the beginning (!). On the bright side, you can stop withdraws if they’ve gone on for 5 years or you’re over 59½.

Let’s say you’re 50 years old with $1,000,000 in your IRA. You could retire now if only you had a way to access it! You decide to look into using a 72(t) to start cashing it out now.

Step 1: Calculate how much you can withdraw each year. This isn’t a simple calculation. I’d recommend using a 72t calculator to compute this. These calculators will give 3 options for how much you can withdraw each year using different computational methods:

The required minimum distribution method bases the amount on your age, life expectancy, and account balance. With this method, you’ll recalculate the withdrawal amount each year based on the previous years’ balance.

The required minimum distribution method. The annual payment for each year is determined by dividing the account balance for that year by the number from the chosen life expectancy table for that year. Under this method, the account balance, the number from the chosen life expectancy table and the resulting annual payments are redetermined for each year. If this method is chosen, there will not be deemed to be a modification in the series of substantially equal periodic payments, even if the amount of payments changes from year to year, provided there is not a change to another method of determining the payments

IRS description of the required minimum distribution method

The fixed amortization method works similar to a mortgage. You calculate out a payout schedule based on the applicable federal rate and your life expectancy. This method matches up with when the account would run out of money if you lived until your life expectancy was up and your money was invested in mid-term government bonds.

Side note: If you’re invested in stocks your money will almost surely last a lot longer.

The fixed amortization method. The annual payment for each year is determined by amortizing in level amounts the account balance over a specified number of years determined using the chosen life expectancy table and the chosen interest rate. Under this method, the account balance, the number from the chosen life expectancy table and the resulting annual payment are determined once for the first distribution year and the annual payment is the

IRS Description of the fixed amortization method

The fixed annuitization method calculates your distribution in the same way an insurance company might. This works by dividing your IRA balance by a lookup field.

The fixed annuitization method. The annual payment for each year is determined by dividing the account balance by an annuity factor that is the present value of an annuity of $1 per year beginning at the taxpayer’s age and continuing for the life of the taxpayer (or the joint lives of the individual and beneficiary). The annuity factor is derived using the mortality table in Appendix B and using the chosen interest rate. Under this method, the account balance, the annuity factor, the chosen interest rate and the resulting annual payment are determined once for the first distribution year and the annual payment is the same amount in each succeeding year

IRS description of the fixed annuitization method

For the example above, our early retiree is a 50-year-old man. According to the IRS, his life expectancy is another 34.2 years. From there you can calculate how much $1 would grow in 34 years assuming the current federal mid-term rate of about 2%.

You can calculate out the annuity factor using this equation in Google Sheets or Excel: =PV(rate, duration, starting balance, ending balance, calculate at beginning of period?). Filing this in with our example we get: =PV(0.02, 34.2, 1, 0, 0).

That’ll return -24.6. $1,000,000 / 24.6 = $40,650.40. That’s the maximum amount they could withdraw using this method.

Once you have the three options, you can choose which one to go with. Your IRA provider will give you a Form 1099-R to file with the IRS when you do your taxes to show what’s happening.

Keep in mind, that you cannot change this amount. If you end up earning additional income later and don’t need the money: that’s too bad. You’ll still need to withdraw it every year and pay taxes on it. Luckily you can stop it after 5 years, but it could be a costly mistake.

72(t) distributions are the least flexible, the most dangerous, require the most paperwork and are the most prone to

Related Articles:

  • 72t Distributions: The Ultimate Guide to Early Retirement

How to Withdraw Funds Early

There are a lot of strategies – each with their own work and pitfalls. In my opinion, the absolute best solution involves the most work upfront but is the most flexible:

During your earning years, save up enough money in a brokerage (after-tax account) to cover:

  • 5+ years of your full spending
  • As many years as needed to reach age 60 with your full spending minus $24,000 a year.

As an example, if you retired at age 50, married, and spend $60,000 a year, you’d need to have (5 x $60,000) + (5 x ($60k-24k)) saved up: or at least $480,000.

With that mix of accounts, you could use the Roth IRA Ladder strategy until you reach 60 all while not paying any taxes during your 50s. All because you limited your IRA to Roth IRA conversions to the standard deduction (the amount you can earn each year without paying taxes on it).

You could roll over $24,000 a year from your IRA to your Roth IRA tax-free. Any long-term capital gains on your brokerage account would also be tax-free if you stay in the 0% long-term capital gains tax bracket.

This approach is similar to our plans to pay no taxes.

Whatever you approach to retirement is, one part is clear: taxes and early withdrawal penalties can make or break your plan. Take the time to craft a plan that minimizing taxes and maximizes your chance of success!

June 2020 Theme: Explore

Written by Adam on June 2, 2020. Updated January 8, 2023.
12 min read. Personal, Goals, Blog. 8 Comments

For all of 2020, I’m trying something different. Every month I’m setting a theme. As part of that theme, I’m also setting goals and habits to help it along the way. These themes aren’t limited to the month either – each theme is for the year but in addition to everything else added before it.

For January my theme was Focus, for February it was Finish, for March, Routine, for April Create and for May Work. I picked these themes based on what I felt was the most important at the time to help stay emotionally grounded, productive, and happy. 

Side note: Check out the bottom of any of these “theme posts” to hear about how it went.

[Read more…] about June 2020 Theme: Explore
  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Go to page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 5
  • Go to page 6
  • Go to page 7
  • Go to page 8
  • Go to page 9
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 43
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

Hi, I’m Adam!

Adam at Megacon

Hey, and Welcome! I’m Adam and I help millennials invest to reach financial independence sooner than they ever thought possible. Want to see what you could do to reach FI sooner? You’re in the right place!

Adam at Megacon

Hey, and Welcome! I’m Adam and I help millennials invest to reach financial independence sooner than they ever thought possible. Want to see what you could do to reach FI sooner? You’re in the right place!

Hi, I’m Adam!

Adam at Megacon

Hey, and Welcome! I’m Adam and I help millennials invest to reach financial independence sooner than they ever thought possible. Want to see what you could do to reach FI sooner? You’re in the right place!

Financial independence through investing, minimalism & mindfulness.

Slow down. Breathe. Relax. Invest. Get a good nights sleep.

Investment Series & Guides

  • The Minimal Investor
  • FIRE Guide
  • The Focused Investor

Categories

  • Investing
  • Financial Independence
  • Minimalism
  • Mindfulness
  • All

Minafi

  • About
  • Contact Me
  • Privacy Policy
  • Brand Assets
  • Advertiser Disclosure
  • How is this site built?